Tuesday, October 20, 2026
TPK Blues
My Redux OD&D game had its first TPK this evening and I am sad about it.
Here’s how it happened: when stocking the level I randomly rolled “Spectres” in room 8 of Level Xi. I then rolled 2d6, and wrote “8. 7 Spectres”. I did this months ago. It’s been set in ink for a long time.
Today a party happened to wander into room 8, and faced 7 6hd monsters who move 12” and can only be hit by magical weapons (they had no magical weapons). They shut the door, but the Spectres rolled a ‘1′ on the pursuit die, indicating that they pursued the party through it. 5 of the 7 attacked the party, and after rolling 30d6 for NRACS it’s determined that 13.5 energy levels are subtracted from each of the front rank. Per the spectre rules, Scott Scooter and Scout Mcphee become spectres , and attack the remaining 4 players. 8 spectres attack: 48d6. I stopped rolling after the result became clear.
Everything was above board here. Room 8 is trivial to avoid. I rolled initiative each time, I rolled the correct pursuit roll. Most of Level Xi isn’t all that dangerous! It just so happens that that particular room contained, like, some of the most dangerous monsters in OD&D.
And yet I am sad. I am sad at the loss of Scott Scooter and Discretion Limor and Windy Silverfox. These are fantastic characters, played excellently by their players, and they’ve been wiped away through no fault of their own. It is a real loss, and one which happened randomly, through the confluence of events. Scott Scooter in particular makes me sad. He was a Hero, who had survived a near-TPK last season to a goblin flamethrower.
Yes, I could have seen “7 spectres” and ignored the note, although I’m glad I didn’t. I could have fudged the dice, I could have made them talking spectres and not attacking ones. And yet I still feel there’s something honest about sticking to what’s been decided beforehand. 7 spectres is what was in that room; once written it was out of my hands. I felt it was my responsibility to go with what was written on the page.
I followed the steps and I am sad.
OD&D players who read this will say “Fuck yeah, that’s what happens!”
OSR players will remark, “If you feel sad, perhaps you should have telegraphed the danger better, given more options to escape it.”
Trad players might be filled with horrified vindication, saying “See what OSR brainrot does? It encourages bad game design which leads to shitty, unfun outcomes.”
For me, I think of it as reaping what I’ve sowed. This is how I have decided to run my games and I’ve got to live with it. The real cost of writing “7 spectres” was hypothetical to me before. I now know what that really means. I think I will continue to put things like that in my dungeons, honestly. I will continue to be sad.
The biggest worry I have is that this experience will make players more cautious, less willing to explore deeply. The thing is, it was just as likely for the players in this expedition to come away with thousands of gold pieces — I have to trust that they know this. People do keep coming back to my game, so I suppose I’m doing something right.
Monday, June 15, 2026
sorry thats not my job
“Prep scenarios, not plots” is a big ole’ touchstone for playing dungeon or field games in my circles. The idea is that it’s not the referee’s job to plan out players’ adventures for them.
What you should do instead is come up with a situation you find interesting and plop it in front of ‘em. Trust your friends who you’re playing with to take your idea seriously and explore it earnestly—and if you’re playing a Fantasy Roleplaying Game with someone you should be at minimum friendly because otherwise what are you even doing?
It’s a trust thing, right, you have to be willing to risk an imperfect game experience in the hopes that your game companions will put in their own kind of investment and make something with you that none of you could do on your own.
So far so good: eager referees are taking notes down for How To Play D&D.
…
Okay but I have another DM Advice I wanna throw out there in the same vein: when writing or drawing stuff, it’s not your job to make it playable.
In the same way it’s the players’ job to make an adventure out of a scenario, it’s the at-the-table referee’s job to make the map/key into a game.
The writer, on the other hand—the version of yourself who that draws the maps and writes the keys and publishes the rules you run? They shouldn’t worry about playability, or even intelligibility. Their job is just to make something inspiring for the oracular art of playing a board game.
High trust is the way. At each stage of the hobby, you have to have faith that those operating the next stage will pick up what you’re putting down, or at least find something worthwhile and run with it.
Don’t worry about making something that’s effective or principled or in accordance with expectations: make something that’s beautiful and engaging to you right now. Life is too short, and play-time is even shorter, to bother with anxiety about whether your near-future hypothetical self will find your work fun.
its all made up anyway
